Feedback Form
   
Add to Google
New Study Shows Solar System is Unique New Study Shows Solar System is Unique
Monday, September 01, 2008 - Shalhevet Bar-Asher
Home >> News >> Space
  Peralink
Research conducted by a team of North American scientists recently claimed that our solar system is special, contrary to the accepted theory that it is an average planetary system. Using computer simulations to follow the development of planets, it was shown that very specific conditions are needed for a proto-stellar disk to evolve into a solar system-like planetary system. The simulations show that in most cases either no planets are created, or planets are formed and then migrate towards the disk center and acquire highly elliptical orbits.

a montage of planetary images taken by spacecraft managed by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena, CA. Included are (from top to bottom) images of Mercury, Venus, Earth (and Moon), Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune. Image credit: NASA/JPL  
a montage of planetary images taken
by spacecraft managed by the
Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena,
CA. Included are (from top to bottom)
images of Mercury, Venus, Earth
(and Moon), Mars, Jupiter,
Saturn, Uranus and Neptune.
(Credit: NASA/JPL)
A planetary system consists of various non stellar objects orbiting a star, such as our sun. Over the past several years more and more planetary systems have been discovered, with varying masses, orbits and other system characteristics. Computer simulations attempting to track the development of a planetary system have been restricted due to computational limitations and the complexity of the problem. The new simulation is the first that is able to track planetary systems, beginning with the disk of gas and dust left behind after the formation of the central star and ending with the planetary system. 

The research was aimed at finding the connection between the properties of the proto-stellar disk and those of its progeny, the planets. A set of 100 simulations, based on data from over 250 planetary systems and spanning 500 million years, was carried out, covering a range of parameters. The two main parameters were the initial disk mass and its viscosity, which determines the rate of gas accretion onto the central star. 

The simulations show that the proto-stellar disk pushes the planets towards the star. As the planets approach each other, their interaction often results in an elongation of their orbits. Occasionally the outcome of these interactions is the flinging of a planet to a different location in the system, or even into deep space. Eventually the gas in the disk is all consumed and the planetary system emerges.

Due to the complexity of the developing system, which includes the disk-planet and planet-planet interactions described, the simulations resulted in random systems. Nevertheless, two dominant cases were detected. 

In a disk with low mass and high viscosity, the gas in the disk is removed before a planet can form, resulting in a system that has only rocky, icy bodies. At the other end, in a disk with high mass and low viscosity, planets are formed but are pulled towards the center of the system and acquire highly elliptical orbits around the star. 

In the intermediate case, planets form but undergo only modest migration towards the star and their orbits don't become as elliptical. This seems to be the case of the solar system. The simulation showed that this case is realized in a small number of systems, meaning the solar system does not resemble most planetary systems. 

One of the scientists who conducted this research, Frederic A. Rasio from Northwestern University in Illinois, said: “We now better understand the process of planet formation and can explain the properties of the strange exoplanets we’ve observed. We also know that the solar system is special and understand at some level what makes it special. The solar system had to be born under just the right conditions to become this quiet place we see. The vast majority of other planetary systems didn’t have these special properties at birth and became something very different.” 

TFOT has reported on the discovery of three planets orbiting a sun 1,000 light years away from earth, on the discovery of a planetary system that may have four suns, and on sixteen extra-solar planet candidates discovered by the Hubble Space Telescope. TFOT also covered the finding of an earth-like planet outside the solar system, which may contain water. 

Further information on the new research, which was published in Science magazine, can be found in the Arxiv website (PDF).

Related News MAVEN - New NASA Mission to Mars MAVEN - New NASA Mission to Mars NASA Outsources ISS Resupply NASA Outsources ISS Resupply

Related Pictures Underground Water on Saturn's Moon Underground Water on Saturn's Moon Ares Super-Chute Tests Ares Super-Chute Tests

Other Articles DARPA's Urban Challenge 2007 DARPA's Urban Challenge 2007 Mempile - Terabyte on a CD Mempile - Terabyte on a CD



Comments & Replies (12)
100 simulations?   (09/02/08 - 8:11 - by Pete)
Yeah, because 100 simulations should be enough.
Shows Solar System is Unique   (09/02/08 - 8:56 - by Edwin Reeves)
The title of this article is so bizarre as to call into question the
editor's understanding of the scientific method. This study shows
nothing about exosolar planetary systems. It suggest, using
simulations based on inferred indirect data, that the solar system in
not the norm. Have the standards of proof really sunk so low?
yeah? really?   (09/02/08 - 9:45 - by anti-thisarticle)
data based on 250 planetary systems? yeah, right. theyre seriously
gonna go and say that the systems they observe here are going to be
under the same conditions somewhere else in the universe or in another
universe altogether. nice one "north american scientists" now we look
that much stupider
initial conditions   (09/02/08 - 9:53 - by Roland)
The problem with these simulations is that we know small differences
in initial conditions can have large effects, and we are not sure
about those initial conditions. Also, tidal forces can move bodies
out, and circularize orbits, as with earth/moon. Is that factored in
these simulations?
Unique ?!?   (09/02/08 - 10:59 - by Russ)
Unfortunate use of that word, given the content of the article.
"Special" would surely be better.
Sheesh.   (09/02/08 - 20:44 - by nighthawk808)
In November 1903, a mathematical proof was given for why
heavier-than-air craft are impossible. Need I remind anyone what the
Wright Brothers did the very next month?

In the 1940's, dozens of scientists "proved" that it was impossible
for anyone to go faster than the speed of sound. In 1947, Chuck Yeager
did just that.

Around 5 billion years ago, the Solar System was formed. Yet these
guys have just "proved" that it can't happen. At least the two
examples I gave above had the excuse of never having had the
phenomenon they "disproved" happen before then. Rasio et al. can't
claim the same ignorance.

I look forward to their follow-up which proves that electricity cannot
be harnessed to perform computations.
You're actually wrong. :\   (09/02/08 - 23:28 - by Uhh)
I can say that because it's not a matter of opinion. It's fact.
You said they proved it *can't happen* when they actually said "it's
unlikely but it happens sometimes"
:\
reply to Uhh's comment   (09/03/08 - 9:36 - by Shalhevet Bar-Asher)
I actually never used the words "can't happen", on the contrary it
says "The simulation showed that this case is realized in a small
number of systems".
Rasio et al should be ashamed.   (09/03/08 - 9:46 - by Chad)
This is the science equivalent of looking at a glass of water and
predicting oceanic currents.

First off, every planetary system is going to be unique (just like
people). Second, we don\'t have anywhere NEAR enough data to make
good simulations. Heck, 20 years ago they were confident planets
would be unlikely outside Sol - and now we find them everywhere.

This ultimately reeks of modelers avoiding science and stoking their
egos.
Biased   (09/03/08 - 14:49 - by Krommeman)
Data of exotic planetary systems give exotic results. We have just
begun discovering planetary systems. The ones we have detected have
been detected because of their bizarre properties.
It's in Science, guys   (09/04/08 - 10:19 - by Rich Deem)
You may not like the implications of the study, but it follows the
trend of the last few years showing that our solar systems is not just
run of the mill. The article is published in Science, the premiere,
peer-reviewed scientific journal (see
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/321/5890/814). Get over
it!
earth   (02/06/09 - 22:11 - by pria)
this is intresting

Add a New Comment
Your name:   0/20
Subject:  0/30
Your Comment:  0/999
Type the following letters: Visual CAPTCHA
Please keep your comments related to the above item's topic. TFOT reserves the right to delete any unrelated comment without notice.

Picture Of The Day
Floating Jelly Hat
Floating Jelly Hat

Video
Paralysed Rats Sprint
Paralysed Rats Sprint

Site Of The Week
Galaxy Zoo
Galaxy Zoo

Personal Column
Detroit’s Dream of Aircraft Production
Dr. Daniel Uziel
Detroit’s Dream of Aircraft Production
Terms Of Use | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Advertise With Us | Site Profile
Copyright © 2007 The Future of Things. All rights reserved.